Almost Certainly Not — And Here’s Why**
Before we get started...this:
Annals of Law Enforcement
Kash Patel’s Acts of Service
The F.B.I. director isn’t just enforcing the President’s agenda at the Bureau—he’s seeking retribution for its past investigations of Donald Trump.
By Marc Fisher (also his interview last night on Fresh Air with Terri Gross on NPR:
How Kash Patel is roiling the FBI and changing its mission
Moving on...
Counterfactuals are tricky, but some historical arcs are clear enough that you can reasonably project the outcome. When it comes to Donald Trump, the truth is this:
Trump was a symptom of a vacuum — a collapse of trust, endless wars, economic anxiety, political cynicism, and a GOP that had exhausted its traditional ideology.
A Gore presidency would have prevented most of that from ever happening.
Let’s walk through the key drivers of Trumpism and how Gore’s presence in the White House would have changed the trajectory.
1. No Iraq War, No Trump
This cannot be overstated.
The Iraq War was the defining strategic disaster of the 21st century:
-
It destabilized the Middle East
-
It birthed ISIS
-
It cost trillions
-
It disillusioned millions of Americans
-
It shattered trust in government
-
It radicalized the right
-
It fueled conspiracy culture
-
It broke the Republican Party’s intellectual spine
-
It turned anti-establishment rage mainstream
Trump exploited every one of these fractures.
Gore would not have invaded Iraq.
Meaning:
➡️ No endless wars
➡️ No mass veteran trauma on this specific scale
➡️ No “the system lied to you” radicalizing event
➡️ No shattered global credibility
➡️ Far less anti-government rage for Trump to weaponize
Donald Trump’s political persona is built on the ruins of that war.
Take away the ruins, and the persona collapses.
2. The Financial Crisis Would Have Been Mitigated — or Hit Differently
The 2008 crash, born from deregulation and complacency, gutted the middle class and fueled resentment.
Bush-era policies contributed to:
-
aggressive deregulation
-
lax oversight
-
ballooning leverage
-
reckless mortgage practices
Gore was a regulator by instinct and an economic realist, not an ideologue.
While the crisis might still have occurred (its roots predated 2001), it likely would have:
-
been less severe
-
hit later, not during a Republican administration
-
been managed with more competence
-
avoided the “Main Street got crushed while Wall Street got bailed out” anger that fueled Trump
Remember: Trump tapped into economic humiliation.
A well-managed 2008 doesn’t birth that same anger.
3. No Katrina-Like Collapse of Federal Competence
Events like Hurricane Katrina told millions of Americans that government was incompetent and indifferent.
That cynicism was a major ingredient in Trumpism.
Gore was obsessive about:
-
planning
-
coordination
-
science
-
climate-related disaster management
There is no universe in which he handles Katrina the way Bush did.
Take away that trauma, and again, less fuel for Trump.
4. Climate Policy Changes Everything
Under Gore, the U.S. would’ve spent the 2000s:
-
building renewable energy
-
taxing carbon or capping emissions
-
investing in green jobs
-
reducing dependence on fossil fuel states and foreign suppliers
This helps:
-
Rust Belt workers
-
rural economies
-
manufacturing
-
public health
-
energy prices
What was Trump’s entire argument in the Rust Belt?
“Globalism stole your jobs. Democrats abandoned you. Only I care about your factories and your towns.”
A decade of green investment would have done the opposite:
It would have brought jobs and hope back a decade earlier.
5. The GOP Would Have Nominated Different People
The Republican Party was drifting but not yet broken in 2000.
The Bush-Cheney years:
-
hollowed out its intellectual core
-
radicalized it
-
empowered neocons, then the Tea Party, then MAGA
-
pushed conspiratorial thinking into the mainstream
-
delegitimized “normal” conservative governance
Without Bush-Cheney:
-
there is no Tea Party of 2010
-
there is no Palin-style populism
-
there is no birther movement
-
there is no Fox News radicalization on the same scale
And without those, Trump has no ladder to climb.
He needs the party already destabilized.
Gore-era competence stabilizes it.
6. Trump Himself Would Have Lost Interest
This matters more than you’d think.
Donald Trump flirted with running for president in:
-
1988
-
2000
-
2012
But what made him finally run in 2016 was a unique convergence of national bitterness, cultural collapse, and political opportunity.
In a stable, prosperous, less-angry America, Trump is just:
➡️ A loud real-estate guy
➡️ A celebrity cameo-maker
➡️ A Howard Stern curiosity
➡️ A Twitter grievance machine
➡️ A guy with an ego, not a political future
He needed chaos to ascend.
Gore’s presidency would not have produced that chaos.
7. No Birtherism = No Trump
Trump built his political identity on one thing:
The racist lie that Barack Obama wasn’t born in the United States.
Would Obama still have become president after eight years of Gore?
Possibly — but with:
-
a less radicalized opposition
-
no Iraq War baggage
-
no Tea Party movement
-
a healthier information ecosystem
-
a less angry electorate
And without a radicalized right-wing machinery, birtherism dies on arrival.
Without birtherism, Trump has no political identity at all.
So, Would Trump Have Happened?
No — not in any meaningful, powerful, or dangerous form.
Could he still have existed as a celebrity?
Sure.
Could he still have posted nonsense online?
Absolutely.
But would he have risen to the presidency, launched a personality cult, destabilized democracy, and rewired the global far right?
Almost certainly not.
History doesn’t create people like Trump out of nowhere.
It requires:
-
distrust
-
chaos
-
humiliation
-
economic fear
-
political exhaustion
-
institutional failure
-
cultural despair
A Gore administration would have prevented, softened, or managed the very forces that created Trump’s opening.
Trump didn’t rise in a vacuum.
He rose from the wreckage of the 2000s.
If that wreckage never happens, neither does he.
Cheers! Sláinte! Na zdravie!
No comments:
Post a Comment