Watch “I wasn’t aware of that” on YouTube:
Against all MaGA/Trumpian toxic conservative disinformation, in 2022, undocumented immigrants contributed $96.7 billion into Social Security & Medicare, and they'll receive nothing. Really, just kinda screwing ourselves there.
Same as we've done with migrant farmworkers?
Exactly—history repeating itself. Just like with farmworkers in the recent past, there’s a push to get undocumented workers out, only to realize too late that they were essential all along. The same thing would happen if they were removed from industries like construction, food service, and elder care.
It's like shooting yourself in the foot and then wondering why you can’t walk.
In 2022, undocumented immigrants contributed significantly to U.S. social programs:
-
Social Security: $25.7 billion
-
Medicare: $6.4 billion
These contributions are part of the approximately $96.7 billion in total taxes paid by undocumented immigrants that year.
Despite these substantial payments, undocumented immigrants are generally ineligible to receive benefits from these programs.
These figures underscore the significant role undocumented immigrants play in supporting U.S. social insurance programs.
Yeah, it's a pretty ironic situation—undocumented workers pump billions into programs they can’t even benefit from, essentially subsidizing Social Security and Medicare for everyone else. If anything, the system relies on their contributions, but they’re demonized instead of acknowledged for it.
-
"They still use public services."
-
Some argue that undocumented immigrants use emergency healthcare, public schools, and infrastructure without paying their "fair share." However, studies show they pay into taxes at local, state, and federal levels while receiving fewer benefits than citizens.
-
-
"They drive down wages."
-
Critics claim undocumented workers undercut wages by accepting lower pay, making it harder for legal residents to compete. However, economists are divided on this, with some finding minimal impact on wages and others noting that undocumented labor fills jobs that many Americans avoid.
-
-
"They're here illegally—tax contributions don't justify breaking the law."
-
This is more of a moral/legal argument than an economic one. The idea is that even if they contribute, it doesn’t excuse their undocumented status. But this ignores the reality that many industries (agriculture, construction, hospitality) depend on undocumented labor.
-
-
"They send money abroad instead of reinvesting in the U.S."
-
Some critics point out that undocumented workers send remittances to their home countries, which doesn't help the U.S. economy. But this ignores the fact that they still spend money on rent, food, transportation, and taxes—stimulating local economies.
-
-
"They take jobs from Americans."
-
This claim assumes a zero-sum job market, which isn't how economies work. In many cases, undocumented workers take low-wage, physically demanding jobs that have persistent labor shortages, rather than positions most Americans are competing for.
-
The reality is that undocumented immigrants contribute significantly to the economy, and removing them would likely create serious financial strain on Social Security, Medicare, and multiple industries. The counterarguments tend to focus on legal or emotional perspectives rather than the hard numbers.
So, there it is. What is our mistake then in all this? Listening to Donald Trump, apparently. Electing him as POTUS45, realizing he's an autocrat destructive to America and democracy, and then, re-electing him to continue his damage to our country, now that he's more astute at our destruction.
When WILL we ever learn? Probably when we realize just how important education is and holding people in power to account.
Yeah, better be soon. Real soon...
Compiled with aid of ChatGPT